Whether we view it in religious, social, political, or economic terms, Christianity has deeply and integrally influenced the Western worldview, our way of life, and our most basic notions of selfhood, morality, and ethics. But compelling controversies surrounding the development of Christianity in its first three centuries bring into question common beliefs about the faith. Now, in The Greatest Controversies of Early Christian History, join award-winning Professor Bart D. Ehrman in a penetrating investigation of these provocative issues of Christianity. In this revealing inquiry, you’ll tackle 24 pivotal controversies from the most important formative era of the faith, investigating them with the tools of the historian and aiming to resolve them with academic rigor.
The Greatest Controversies of Early Christian History
Uncover secrets and learn the truth behind some of the most persistent and provocative controversies of early Christianity in this gripping course by noted biblical scholar and New York Times best-selling author Bart D. Ehrman.
Rated 5 out of
5
by
Steve745 from
I always enjoy Mr. Ehrman's lectures. This series, to me, is his most accessible course to date--at least partly because it is organized as a sequence of FAQs, a old and reliable organizational structure. I am always baffled by Christians who find his teachings so threatening. He is crystal clear that history is history and faith is faith. Each addresses a different aspect of our understanding and experience of the world.
Date published: 2024-12-05
Rated 5 out of
5
by
Peter Sibly from
Facinating subject, supurb instructor
This is an outstanding course. Prof. Ehrman has such an educated yet intimate style of presentation, I found myself glued to the screen from the beginning to end of each lesson. Highly, highly recommended.
Date published: 2024-11-25
Rated 5 out of
5
by
Bd10 from
Another Outstanding course by Professor Ehrman
I have taken almost all of Professor Ehrman’s courses. This was another outstanding course. This is the way religion should be taught from historical, evidence based perspective rather than theological perspective. For those who are interested in the latter , this is not a course for you. You will be better off to go to church and let the minister preach at you so you enjoy hearing what you believe in!
But I think this course especially focused on the common controversies is an eye opener for faithful Christians if they want to know about the Bible, its development and those books which were excluded from the New Testament.
Date published: 2024-11-07
Rated 5 out of
5
by
the professor from
Forensic Investigation into early christian canon.
As is the standard with all courses by Professor Bart D Ehrman, this lecture set is a very deep dive in historical religious foundational documents. The Professor meticulously details the reason for religious concerns and provides the Learner with minute level of supporting documents. Dr. Erdman is pleasure to behold and I found myself mesmerized by his delivery, which presented in robust, passionate manner. Every topic was extremely fascinating and riveting due to the solid supporting detail.I found this set especially meaningful as I attended Catholic school fro k-12, and everyday we had are religion class and were told what to believe and not to think any diverting thoughts. Every topic was fascinating, I am not going to single out one individual lecture topic as everyone is so stimulating. The research detail and topic support was excellent. This is worth the investment from every aspect! I highly recomment this course.
Date published: 2024-11-05
Rated 5 out of
5
by
Jerzy from
An excelent course
I have taken all the Great Courses offered by Dr Ehrman and consider him one of the top professors. The subject of this course was fascinating and was well organized and presented. I was very impressed by his scholarly knowledge and ability to impart the information in an interesting and understandable manner.
Date published: 2024-10-24
Rated 5 out of
5
by
wcsj from
Best Video I have ever seen on Christian History!
The professor provides a clear and thorough explanation of Christianity's controversies. As a result, I have a much better understanding of how Christianity came to be!
Date published: 2024-10-22
Rated 5 out of
5
by
Observe And Report from
Another Fantastic Course from Bart Ehrman
I've completed several courses by the same lecturer on the history of early Christianity, so I already had some prior knowledge, but I still learnt plenty of new things in every lecture of this course. Bart Ehrman is an engaging speaker who's not only clearly an expert, but knows how to present the material in a clear and interesting way. If you're interested in the history of early Christianity, I heartily recommend this course.
Date published: 2024-10-21
Overview
About
Bart D. Ehrman is the James A. Gray Distinguished Professor at The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. He received his MDiv and PhD from Princeton Theological Seminary. He has written or edited more than 30 books, including six New York Times bestsellers: Misquoting Jesus; God’s Problem; Jesus, Interrupted; Forged; How Jesus Became God; and The Triumph of Christianity. He has also received several teaching honors, including the John William Pope Center Spirit of Inquiry Award and the UNC Students’ Undergraduate Teaching Award.
Trailer
01: Was Jesus Born in Bethlehem?
Begin by considering why the controversies of early Christianity matter, and explore the critical difference between the perspective of the historian and the perspective of faith. Then grapple with the controversy over where Jesus was born, the historical indications, and the faith-based motives for affirming Bethlehem as his birthplace.
32 min
02: Was Jesus’s Mother a Virgin?
Belief in the virgin birth has been enormously important throughout the history of Christianity. Here, assess the theological underpinnings of this belief and the role of Mary as a divine figure. Investigate accounts of the Annunciation in Matthew and Luke, and grasp their reasons for claiming Mary conceived as a virgin.
27 min
03: Did Jesus Have a Twin Brother?
The question of whether Jesus had siblings divided early Christians, a controversy that survives to this day. Learn about the non-canonical Acts of Thomas and its account of the missionary Didymus Judas Thomas, portrayed as Jesus’s identical twin brother, and consider how early Christians might have thought about this.
25 min
04: Is Jesus in the Dead Sea Scrolls?
Discover the Dead Sea Scrolls as they shed important light on the historical Jesus and on Jewish life in his time. Learn how the scrolls express the worldview of Jewish apocalypticism, shared by Jesus, which anticipated the end of the age and the establishment of a new kingdom on Earth.
28 min
05: Did Jesus Expect to See the World’s End?
Grasp how scholars and historians have approached the historical accuracy of the Gospels, and track the developing critical view of Jesus as an apocalyptic prophet. Contemplate the core tenets of Jesus’s teachings regarding the coming kingdom of God, and how his views threatened the social order of his time.
33 min
06: How Close Were Jesus and Mary Magdalene?
First assess the inaccurate portrayal of Mary Magdalene in novels and film, and trace the church tradition regarding her as a prostitute. Then review the known facts concerning Jesus’s female followers, Mary’s place in his ministry, and her likely role in his legacy both within his lifetime and afterward.
26 min
07: Was Jesus Married?
The idea that Jesus was married is purportedly supported by statements in the Talmud on ancient Jewish life. Investigate the marriage practices of early Judaism and the social reality of celibacy. Examine the role of apocalyptic thinking in affirming a life of celibacy, as seen in the teachings of Paul, the Essenes, and Jesus himself.
26 min
08: What Secrets Did Judas Betray?
For the last century, scholars have disagreed on the nature of Judas’s betrayal of Jesus. Delve into the historical record concerning the figure of Judas, and trace contrasting views of his motives. Review pertinent facts surrounding Jesus’s death and evidence that what Judas divulged to the authorities was a justification for destroying Jesus.
28 min
09: Did the Jews Kill Jesus?
The issue of the Jewish role in Jesus’s death became the basis for Christian anti-Semitism. To elucidate this crucial matter, investigate the events of Jesus’s final week in Jerusalem, the incendiary atmosphere surrounding the celebration of Passover, and the nature of the Jewish authorities’ response to Jesus prior to the trial and crucifixion.
30 min
10: Was Pontius Pilate a Secret Christian?
The ruthless Roman governor who ordered Jesus crucified has undergone a character change over the course of Christian history. Study portrayals of Pilate in Christian storytelling, the Gospels, and non-canonical writings as they seek to exonerate him from culpability in Jesus’s death. Grapple with these sources’ reasons for downplaying Pilate’s role in Jesus’s execution.
28 min
11: Was Jesus Raised from the Dead?
In approaching what is perhaps the greatest Christian controversy of all, learn about ancient views of the afterlife and the meaning of resurrection in the world Jesus inhabited. Investigate scholarship on visionary experience, and the role of visions in the conviction among the first believers that Jesus was in fact resurrected.
28 min
12: Did the Jews Expect a Suffering Messiah?
In this lecture, trace the early Jewish conception of a future mashiach as a figure of power and grandeur, and the Christian view that a suffering messiah was predicted in the Jewish scriptures. Study the relevant scriptural passages and the core arguments dividing Christians and Jews on this critical issue.
25 min
13: Is Paul the Real Founder of Christianity?
This lecture digs deeply into the distinction between the teachings of Jesus and the Christian view of his death and resurrection that has defined the faith. Learn about Paul’s theology and the striking differences between his and Jesus’s views of the coming kingdom, in grasping Paul’s precise role in the new religion.
27 min
14: Did the Disciples Write the Gospels?
The matter of the authorship of the New Testament Gospels has important ramifications for understanding the historical Jesus. Investigate the dating of the Gospels, our historical knowledge of Matthew, John, Mark, and Luke, and the question of whether they possessed the skills to have written such highly literary narratives.
30 min
15: Does the New Testament Contain Forgeries?
False claims of authorship for religious writings were common in the early church. First, trace the phenomenon of literary forgery in the ancient world, and its broad condemnation. Then study the range of New Testament writings of questionable authorship, and consider the motives for false attribution and how they were justified.
31 min
16: Is the Book of Revelation about Our Future?
The book of Revelation stands as a provocative focal point of the New Testament. To grasp its meaning and significance, learn about the genre of ancient apocalyptic literature, Revelation’s place in that tradition, and what its contents were intended to convey to people living at the time of its writing.
28 min
17: Who Were the Original Christians?
Here, explore the diversity of Christianity in the 2nd century, when multiple groups claimed to represent the “original” faith. Illuminate this issue by tracing the various forms of Gnosticism, the traditional conception of orthodoxy, and evidence that what we think of as Christian orthodoxy today was in fact a later development.
28 min
18: Is the True Jesus in the Gnostic Gospels?
This lecture highlights striking contrasts in theological conceptions of Jesus found among early Christian groups. With regard to Jesus’s divinity, uncover the views of the Adoptionists, the Marcionists, and the “separationist” view of Gnosticism in determining whether the Gnostic Gospels represent the understanding of Jesus’s earliest followers.
30 min
19: What Happened to the Apostles?
Stories about the later lives of Jesus’s apostles abound within the Christian tradition. Here, distinguish fact from legend by investigating the Apocryphal Acts of the Apostles, the non-canonical texts concerning Peter, Paul, Thomas, John, and Andrew. Evaluate these texts’ historical reliability and their significance for understanding Christianity.
28 min
20: Was Christianity an Illegal Religion?
The relationship of the early Christians to the Roman state is often obscured by historical inaccuracies and misperceptions. Learn about the variety of religious practices permitted by Rome, citizens’ obligations regarding social order and participation in the state religion, and perceptions of certain early Christian practices that led to the Christians’ persecution.
27 min
21: Is the Old Testament a Christian Book?
Investigate the place of the Jewish scriptures in the lives of Jesus and his followers and how Christian views of Jewish law changed during Paul’s mission. Trace diverse views of the Old Testament in the 2nd century in grasping how it became accepted as a Christian text.
28 min
22: Did Early Christians Accept the Trinity?
With regard to this core Christian doctrine, learn about the earliest theological understanding of Jesus by his followers, and track changing views of Jesus’s divinity in the 2nd and 3rd centuries. Grasp the thrust of the “Arian controversy,” debated at the famous Council of Nicea, which clarified the Christian understanding of the Trinity.
28 min
23: Do We Have the Original New Testament?
Drawing on current scholarship and methodology, learn about how books were produced, copied, and circulated in the ancient world, and the role of professional scribes in preserving literary materials. Identify the earliest surviving texts of the New Testament, their inconsistencies, and what we can say about their originality.
31 min
24: Who Chose the Books of the New Testament?
Finally, delve into the intriguing question of how the final form of the New Testament came to be—who decided on the 27 books, when the decision was made, and on what grounds. Conclude by considering why Christianity, in particular, is prone to controversy and likely to remain so.
32 min
