Utopia and Terror in the 20th Century

Rated 4 out of 5 by from entirely worth a visit though Professor Liulevicius' presentation is not quite as objective as one would like from an historian, his picture of the violent 20th Century remains nevertheless instructive, convincing, and utterly compelling, if not inspiring
Date published: 2020-08-01
Rated 3 out of 5 by from Solid Course with some Hiccups As COVID19 quarantine dragged on in my part of the country, I decided to take this course. It is a topic of interest to me as I grew up during the Cold War and had many veterans of WWII as relatives. The lectures were interesting for the most part but many aspects of history which I had been looking forward to were given very short shrift. The lecture on WWII for example included all of 35 seconds on Japan's involvement and the shape that totalitarianism took in that country. Conversely, almost four entire lectures were expended on Hitler and the Holocaust which was excessive in my view particularly as the same points were made over and over and over again. I was non-plussed by some of the characterizations of actions as "terror" most notably the use of retaliation against civilian populations for supporting guerillas. By that standard I am afraid many nations continue to be guilty of "terror". The professor also appears overly-inspired by one or two philosophers and cites them repeatedly during his lectures (most notably Hannah Arendt). On balance the course held my interest and provided me with some variations on insights into the interplay between the related concepts of terror and utopia. That being said, I did not find the professor as inspiring or as captivating as many of the other professorsin the Great Courses (most notably Professor Gallagher and Aldrete). Not sorry I took the course biut I would not go out of my way to take another course with this professor.
Date published: 2020-05-22
Rated 5 out of 5 by from Should be required in all schools While I learned only a modest amount (because I have read about and studies many of the topics) I think this course should be mandated for all high schools and colleges lest our young generations fail to understand the issues addressed. The lecturer does an excellent job. The only small criticism is that in the lecture on "Soviet Civilization", wherein the lecturer presents a crtitique of "Soviet Realist" art, examples of this perverse "art" form should have been included.
Date published: 2020-05-03
Rated 4 out of 5 by from Complicated topics versus uncertain conclusions. This course explored historical issues and events that, in many instances, are still unresolved and subject to widely varying interpretations and availability of reliable facts upon which to rely. At the conclusion of the course, the "student" will almost certainly be left with many unresolved questions to further ponder. The course was presented with much care and energy.
Date published: 2020-03-19
Rated 5 out of 5 by from Excellent and extremely informative The instructor is most excellent. Although I lived through many of the events included in the course, I learned so much that I never knew before. I particularly appreciated the sections on more recent events, even though I found myself somewhat upset by the violence described and, in many cases, the apathy of the world's nations towards modern genocides. I am so glad to have this information. I'm not sure how I'll use it just yet, but I definitely feel wiser.
Date published: 2020-02-18
Rated 5 out of 5 by from Failed political experiments and their aftermath Prof. Liulevicius is one of the few TGC profs whose courses I purchase almost instinctively; the subject matter isn’t the first consideration, because I simply enjoy their teaching and know that I’ll be in for a good “ride.” He’s a specialist on European history, so his courses on WW1, Espionage, etc. have been especially enlightening. This course, which came out in 2003, is a sort of “top ten” of the 20th century’s most heinous political movements, bringing together such villains as Lenin, Stalin, Mussolini, Hitler, Mao, Pol Pot, the Kim family, and Saddam Hussein. In each case, these leaders promised some sort of utopian society, whether it was Lenin’s worker’s paradise, or Pol Pot’s agrarian Eden. But to achieve these, they had to exert more and more control over their subjects, eliminating enemies and leaving millions of dead citizens in their wake. The Prof draws comparisons between them and their philosophies, and gives us valuable background information (especially on the lesser-known movements). Keep in mind as you listen that this course is already over 15 years old, but one benefit of TGC’s older courses is a more comprehensive guidebook with glossary, timeline, and bio sketches.
Date published: 2020-02-16
Rated 4 out of 5 by from A pretty good basic survey course Overall, I am glad I watched all 25 lectures. On the positive side this is a pretty good general survey course heavily weighted towards the communist, fascist, and Nazi atrocities of the 20th century. The professor has a very good speaking and presentation style. Body language, speech, pacing all good - nothing distracting in the least. Pleasant to listen to. I feel that I did not learn very much that was new to me, but someone with less grounding in 20th century world history there would probably be much new to learn here. On the downside, I really did get the feel this was a basic survey course that left out a lot of context and neglected other topics that could have been considered. The course was heavily weighted towards European totalitariansism, communism, and Naziism. I feel an opportunity was lost here to think about how terror has been used more globally - the dictatorships of Latin America were not even mentioned, I do not think apartheid in South Africa even came up one. And there is never a bad time to practice a little introspection and reflect the use of terror used in the the western liberal democracies in the third world in the colonial empires, and even domestically. On balance, I am glad I watched it, but came away with the feel I had really sat through an incomplete and fairly basic survey course.
Date published: 2019-06-23
Rated 4 out of 5 by from The Lesson is Missing A solid historical overview of state sponsored terror during the 20th century. A fair subtitle for the series would be State Sponsored Genocides. It's mostly history, with relatively little analysis. He mentions Arendt several times, and seems to think that her work on Totalitarianism will become a classic. I don't think it will. He disappointingly fails to draw the lines connecting the ideas of statism -- whether called "socialist" "communist" "nazi" "fascist" "baathist" or whatever -- and the murder, by the state, of citizens. Even in the US, where the "war on drugs" has usurped the idea of individual rights, the state murders (via 'no knock' raids) with impunity and a stamp of "legitimacy." The scale is certainly different, but the principle not so much. We identify a group we don't like, then license the state to use deadly force to eliminate them. If history is to be any more valuable than comics, we must learn from it. And the lesson from the 20th century must surely be: limit state power to the maximum extent possible. There is no even remotely explicit drawing of this lesson in this course.
Date published: 2019-05-16
  • y_2020, m_10, d_18, h_16
  • bvseo_bulk, prod_bvrr, vn_bulk_3.0.12
  • cp_1, bvpage1
  • co_hasreviews, tv_19, tr_102
  • loc_en_CA, sid_8313, prod, sort_[SortEntry(order=SUBMISSION_TIME, direction=DESCENDING)]
  • clientName_teachco
  • bvseo_sdk, p_sdk, 3.2.1
  • CLOUD, getReviews, 4.25ms
  • REVIEWS, PRODUCT
Defining Utopia and Terror
1: Defining Utopia and Terror

The 20th century saw the rise of brutal ideological regimes that promised total solutions. The key elements of such modern regimes are: 1) masses, 2) machines and mechanisms for control, 3) the seizure of the state by mobsters (political criminals), and 4) ideological master plans....

33 min
The Legacy of Revolutions
2: The Legacy of Revolutions

Nineteenth-century revolutions set the agenda for the 20th century. The French Revolution ushered in a new mass politics, while the Industrial Revolution created new productive power and confidence in science and progress. Both contributed to "utopian socialism," the point of departure for further revolutions....

30 min
Omens of Conflict
3: Omens of Conflict

The 20th century began with optimism, but darker omens also appeared: the growing influence of Marxism, a wave of anarchist terrorism and assassinations, the brutal rule of worldwide imperialism, and premonitions of a coming world war....

31 min
World War I
4: World War I

World War I brutalized Western civilization through such innovations as poison gas, aerial bombing, and targeting of civilians....

31 min
Total War-Mobilization and Mass Death
5: Total War-Mobilization and Mass Death

This lecture considers implications of modern industrial war, or "total war," including use of violence against civilians, expansion of strong central states, propaganda as a tool of persuasion, and modern genocide: the massacre of a million Armenians in 1915....

29 min
Total Revolution in Russia
6: Total Revolution in Russia

Total war led to a new kind of political upheaval: total revolution. Led by Vladimir Ilyich Lenin, the Bolsheviks seized control of Russia in 1917 and began a vast revolutionary experiment....

31 min
War's Aftermath-The Hinge of Violence
7: War's Aftermath-The Hinge of Violence

The peace treaty of Versailles set the terms for new conflicts that inevitably arose. The little-known movements of millions of refugees displaced by the war set a dire precedent for subsequent massive "population transfers."...

31 min
Communism
8: Communism

This lecture traces the early outlines of Soviet power: the establishment of the Cheka secret police and the Red Army, the use of propaganda campaigns, the repression of internal dissent, and, after Lenin's death, the emergence of Josef Stalin....

31 min
Stalin
9: Stalin

Josef Stalin, the "Man of Steel," made himself synonymous with the state. This lecture examines obscure beginnings, his rise to power, and the cult of personality deliberately crafted around him....

32 min
Soviet Civilization
10: Soviet Civilization

The new society of the U.S.S.R. was self-consciously revolutionary and modern, heralding the construction of a "new man" and "new woman." Foreign visitors enthusiastically hailed what they saw as a vision of the "future that works."...

31 min
Fascism
11: Fascism

Coming to power in 1922 through the falsely mythologized "March on Rome," the Fascists brutalized their opponents, prepared to mobilize society in a "total state," and chanted slogans of "Believe, Obey, and Fight." The Fascist style of "Il Duce," Mussolini, was imitated by would-be dictators worldwide....

31 min
The 1930's-"The Low Dishonest Decade"
12: The 1930's-"The Low Dishonest Decade"

The 1930's were marked by deepening worldwide economic crisis, the rejection of liberal ideas, and the ominous revival of imperialist desires. Poet W.H. Auden called it the "low dishonest decade." The Japanese invasion of China foreshadowed World War II, while the Spanish Civil War was its dress rehearsal....

30 min
Nazism
13: Nazism

This lecture surveys the origins of the Nazi movement, its ideological roots, and its rise to power in Germany. All of these were linked to the brutalizing legacies of World War I....

31 min
Hitler
14: Hitler

Adolf Hitler, the man behind the Nazi movement, was indispensable to its success and its growing radicalism. This lecture profiles Hitler and considers the keys to his effectiveness as a dictator, in particular his capability for boundlessly cynical propaganda....

31 min
World War II
15: World War II

The Second World War was unleashed by Hitler in 1939 with help from Stalin. On all sides, this "perfected" total war resulted in massive civilian casualties, especially in war from the air, culminating in the opening of the atomic age....

32 min
Nazi Genocide and Master Plans
16: Nazi Genocide and Master Plans

This lecture considers the Nazis' program of mass murder against the Jews, beginning with escalating persecutions and culminating with extermination camps like Auschwitz....

32 min
The Cold War
17: The Cold War

No sooner had World War II ended than a new confrontation emerged: ideological blocs of countries faced off against one another in the Cold War....

32 min
Mao
18: Mao

After decades of civil war and struggle, Chinese Communists came to power in 1949 under the leadership of Mao Zedong. This lecture examines the society formed by the ideology of "Mao Thought," the "Little Red Book," the uniform dress of "Mao suits," and the cultural break with a rich past forced by the regime....

31 min
Cambodia and Pol Pot's Killing Fields
19: Cambodia and Pol Pot's Killing Fields

In 1975, Cambodian Communist leaders educated in France and led by the mysterious Pol Pot turned their own land into a social experiment. In the three years of their rule, the Khmer Rouge killed some 2 million people, more than 25 percent of Cambodians....

32 min
East Germany, the Soviet Union, North Korea
20: East Germany, the Soviet Union, North Korea

During the Cold War, different variants of communist regimes emerged. The German Democratic Republic was considered a success story. In the Soviet Union, the system lurched towards stagnation. North Korea enshrined its militarized isolation from the world in the ideology of "juche" or self-reliance....

31 min
From the Berlin Wall to the Balkans
21: From the Berlin Wall to the Balkans

As the 20th century neared its end, the spirit of the times sent mixed signals. From 1989 to 1991, Communist regimes in Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union fell with astonishing speed. Yet, as Yugoslavia began to crumble, Europe saw a reversion to the crimes that had marked World War II....

31 min
Rwanda
22: Rwanda

In 1994, horrific events unfolded in the central African country of Rwanda. The Hutu-dominated government organized the mass murder of the Tutsi minority. In 100 days, 800,000 people were slaughtered; the international community failed to intervene....

30 min
Saddam Hussein's Iraq
23: Saddam Hussein's Iraq

This lecture traces how Hussein established his personal dictatorship in Iraq, modeling himself on long-ago despots and surrounding himself with elite Republican Guards. His eight-year war against Iran resembled World War I in its ferocity....

32 min
The Future of Terror
24: The Future of Terror

Ultimately, what are the lessons of the 20th century's linked experiences of the promise of utopia and the reality of terror? This lecture poses the urgent question of how to be vigilant against the revival of movements such as those surveyed, and examines the growing appeal of Arab radicalism and groups like al-Qa'ida. The question of whether these global trends are likely to continue is of vital...

33 min
Vejas Gabriel Liulevicius

Modernity is a notoriously slippery concept, because, obviously, what is modern now will soon become the past, as time marches relentlessly forward.

ALMA MATER

University of Pennsylvania

INSTITUTION

University of Tennessee

About Vejas Gabriel Liulevicius

Dr. Vejas Gabriel Liulevicius is Lindsay Young Professor of History and Director of the Center for the Study of War and Society at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville. He earned his B.A. from the University of Chicago and his Ph.D. from the University of Pennsylvania. After receiving his doctorate, Dr. Liulevicius served as a postdoctoral research fellow at the Hoover Institution on War, Revolution, and Peace at Stanford University. Professor Liulevicius has won many awards and honors, including the University of Tennessee's Excellence in Teaching Award and a National Endowment for the Humanities Fellowship. At the university he teaches courses on modern German history, Western civilization, European diplomatic history, Nazi Germany, World War I, war and culture, 20th-century Europe, nationalism, and utopian thought. Dr. Liulevicius has published numerous articles and two books: War Land on the Eastern Front: Culture, National Identity, and German Occupation in World War I and The German Myth of the East, 1800 to the Present.

Professor Liulevicius participated in The Great Courses Professor Chat series. Read the chat to learn more about diplomacy and war

Also By This Professor